Close Menu
  • English
  • Featured
    • AI & Robotics
    • Energy
    • Finance
    • Leisure
    • Science
    • Security
    • Sustainable Development
    • Tech
    • Transport
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

News, investigations, and analysis — our top stories every morning to start your day right.

Trending
Illustration of a Cybertruck on autopilot with its driver playing Grand Theft Auto V on a highway. Image generated by AI.
Shocking Highway Scene as Man Lets His Cybertruck Drive Autonomously While He Plays Grand Theft Auto Behind the Wheel
Illustration of humanoid robots engaged in a kickboxing match in Hangzhou, China. Image generated by AI.
“Robots in the Ring”: These Two Humanoid Fighters Are Kickboxing With Shocking Agility in a Spectacle That Blurs Man and Machine
Illustration of artificial intelligence impacting gender equality in the workplace. Image generated by AI.
“AI Targets Women First”: Chilling Report Reveals How Automation Is Set to Erase Female-Dominated Jobs at Unprecedented Speed
Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn RSS
Rude Baguette
Facebook X (Twitter) RSS
Newsletter
  • Featured
  • AI
    Illustration of humanoid robots engaged in a kickboxing match in Hangzhou, China. Image generated by AI.

    “Robots in the Ring”: These Two Humanoid Fighters Are Kickboxing With Shocking Agility in a Spectacle That Blurs Man and Machine

    June 16, 2025 at 4:53 PM
    Illustration of artificial intelligence impacting gender equality in the workplace. Image generated by AI.

    “AI Targets Women First”: Chilling Report Reveals How Automation Is Set to Erase Female-Dominated Jobs at Unprecedented Speed

    June 16, 2025 at 4:05 PM
    Illustration of artificial intelligence taking over entry-level job tasks. Image generated by AI.

    “The Real Threat Isn’t Your Job”: AI Isn’t Taking Careers—It’s Replacing People Still Learning to Work, and It’s Happening Fast

    June 16, 2025 at 9:04 AM
    Illustration of Anthropic's vision of ethical artificial intelligence development with Claude as a central figure. Image generated by AI.

    “If Anthropic Succeeds, Everything Changes”: A Nation of Benevolent AI Geniuses Could Rise and Reshape the Future of Human Civilization

    June 15, 2025 at 8:51 AM
    Illustration of Meta's $14.3 billion investment in Scale AI to boost its AI capabilities. Image generated by AI.

    “Meta Drops $14 Billion on AI Bet”: Massive Investment in Scale Signals Desperate Push to Catch OpenAI and Regain Tech Dominance

    June 15, 2025 at 8:11 AM
  • Energy
    Illustration of the innovative process by MIT researchers to produce hydrogen using recycled soda cans and seawater. Image generated by AI.

    From Soda to Superfuel: Researchers Use Coca-Cola and Ocean Water to Produce Clean Hydrogen for the Future of Mobility

    June 13, 2025 at 8:11 AM
    Illustration of China's Hualong-1 nuclear reactor and its impact on global energy dynamics. Image generated by AI.

    “France on the Brink”: China’s Nuclear Reactor Threatens to Wipe Out the Last Stronghold of French Economic Power

    June 12, 2025 at 4:05 PM
    Illustration of a groundbreaking electrochemical reactor for lithium extraction and its impact on sustainable technology. Image generated by AI.

    “U.S. Uncovers Rare Earth Bombshell”: This Shocking Discovery Could Flip the Global Tech Supply Chain on Its Head

    June 12, 2025 at 8:04 AM
    Illustration of the impact of political uncertainty on the U.S. green energy sector. Image generated by AI.

    “Massive Setback in US Energy Sector”: Over 14 Billion Dollars in Hydrogen, Battery, and Solar Projects Canceled or Delayed

    June 11, 2025 at 8:55 AM
    Illustration of the NEOM Green Hydrogen project in Saudi Arabia, highlighting its renewable energy infrastructure. Image generated by AI.

    “NEOM’s Green Hydrogen Mega-Factory Nears Completion”: The Massive Facility Is on the Brink of Launching Revolutionary Sustainable Energy Production

    June 11, 2025 at 8:05 AM
  • Finance
    Illustration of James Howells searching for his lost Bitcoin hard drive in a landfill. Image generated by AI.

    “He’s Still Digging”: Man Who Lost $700 Million in Bitcoin 12 Years Ago in a Dump Faces Stunning New Twist in His Hunt

    June 13, 2025 at 9:05 AM
    Illustration of a lost hard drive containing 8,000 Bitcoins buried in a landfill. Image generated by AI.

    He Just Gave Up €200 Million in Bitcoin: After 12 Years of Digging Through Trash, the Lost Hard Drive Is Gone for Good

    May 30, 2025 at 7:14 AM
    Illustration of a man sleeping with black tape over his lips. Image generated by AI.

    “Doctors Sound the Alarm”: Viral Mouth Taping Trend Called Dangerous and Completely Unproven by Leading Medical Experts

    May 25, 2025 at 8:02 AM
    Illustration of Visa's integration of AI systems into digital payments (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    Visa’s AI Is Now Shopping for You: This Robot May Soon Swipe Your Card Automatically—and Mess With Your Mind

    May 4, 2025 at 8:07 AM
    Microsoft Strikes Unprecedented Deal: World's Largest CO2 Removal at 7.44 Million Tons, Setting New Environmental Milestone

    “Microsoft Strikes Historic Climate Deal”: World’s Largest CO2 Removal Pact Targets 6.75 Million Tons in Unmatched Green Push

    April 19, 2025 at 9:55 AM
  • Leisure
    Illustration of the decline in European tourism to the United States due to geopolitical tensions. Image generated by AI.

    “Europe Turns Its Back on America”: Massive Travel Boycott Slams U.S. Tourism Industry as Revenues Plunge and Destinations Empty Out

    June 16, 2025 at 10:08 AM
    Illustration of two Nintendo Switch bundles with different box designs. Image generated by AI.

    “He Ordered Two, Got Chaos Instead”: Nintendo Fan Buys Identical Switch Packs and Unboxes Two Completely Different Surprises

    June 14, 2025 at 9:55 AM
    Illustration of GTA VI's dynamic and interactive urban environment. Image generated by AI.

    “GTA VI Goes Full Chaos”: Robbable Skyscrapers, Advanced Destruction, and a World That Strikes Back at Every Move

    June 12, 2025 at 12:08 PM
    Illustration of a camping tent with a panoramic roof designed for stargazing. Image generated by AI.

    “Sleep Under the Stars, Literally”: This Inverted Tent Redefines Camping With a Mind-Blowing View of the Night Sky

    June 12, 2025 at 8:47 AM
    Illustration of the vast open world of The Elder Scrolls II: Daggerfall. Image generated by AI.

    “29-Year-Old Game Dwarfs GTA 5”: This Open-World Legend Is 2,000 Times Bigger and Still Has No Real Competition Today

    June 2, 2025 at 9:13 AM
  • Science
    Illustration of astronomers using artificial intelligence to study supermassive black holes. Image generated by AI.

    “A.I. Cracks the Black Hole Code”: Astronomers Use Artificial Intelligence to Reveal Hidden Forces at the Heart of the Universe

    June 15, 2025 at 5:08 PM
    Illustration of independent evolution of intelligence in birds and mammals. Image generated by AI.

    “Intelligence Evolved Twice on Earth”: This Groundbreaking Discovery Redefines Life Itself and Shakes the Foundations of Evolutionary Science

    June 15, 2025 at 11:55 AM
    Illustration of SpaceX Dragon capsule returning to Earth with advanced technology and experiments from the ISS. Image generated by AI.

    “We Brought the Future Back to Earth”: SpaceX Dragon Returns With 6,700 Pounds of Next-Gen Robots After Daring Orbital Operation

    June 15, 2025 at 5:54 AM
    Illustration of SpaceX's vision for a human colony on Mars. Image generated by AI.

    “Mars Is No Longer a Dream”: SpaceX’s Vision Evolves From Bold Idea to Concrete Plan for Multi-Million Human Colony

    June 13, 2025 at 6:00 AM
    Illustration of a shape-recovering liquid forming a Grecian urn shape. Image generated by AI.

    Groundbreaking Discovery by Student: Accidental Creation of a ‘Shape-Recovering Liquid’ Defies the Fundamental Laws of Thermodynamics

    June 11, 2025 at 4:57 PM
  • Security
    Illustration of a Chinese satellite capable of identifying human faces from over 62 miles away. Image generated by AI.

    “China Can See Your Face From Space”: New Spy Satellite Sparks Global Alarm With Its Unprecedented Orbital Surveillance Power

    June 10, 2025 at 3:53 PM
    Illustration of the F-15E Strike Eagle equipped with APKWS II rockets targeting drones. Image generated by AI.

    “We’ll Swat Them Out of the Sky”: U.S. Air Force Upgrades F-15E With 42 Drone-Killing Rockets in Explosive Power Boost

    May 28, 2025 at 10:00 AM
    Illustration of using Starlink satellites to detect stealth aircraft. Image generated by AI.

    “Elon Musk Cornered by Invisible Threat”: China’s New Tech Can Hijack Starlink Satellites and Unmask Stealth Aircraft

    May 27, 2025 at 12:02 PM
    Illustration of Homeland Security revoking Harvard's foreign student program due to alleged China ties. Image generated by AI.

    U.S. Government Revokes Harvard’s Foreign Student Access After Explosive Findings of Deep Connections to China

    May 26, 2025 at 11:56 AM
    Illustration of a damaged North Korean naval destroyer at launch. Image generated by AI.

    “North Korea’s Warship Launch Fails”: Second Naval Destroyer Suffers Major Damage in Stunning Blow to Kim’s Military Ambitions

    May 25, 2025 at 11:48 AM
  • Impact
    Illustration of the world's largest 3D construction printer installed at a school site in Doha, Qatar. Image generated by AI.

    Qatar Installs Giant 3D Beast: World’s Largest Construction Printer Could Reshape Cities and Shake Up the Global Building Industry

    June 12, 2025 at 9:52 AM
    Illustration of the Jeddah Economic Company Tower under construction in the Saudi Arabian desert. Image generated by AI.

    “Skyline Will Never Be the Same”: Saudi Arabia’s Tower Surges Past All Records as World’s Tallest Skyscraper Rises in Blinding Speed

    June 8, 2025 at 4:54 PM
    Illustration of the Jeddah Economic Company Tower rising in the Saudi Arabian desert as the future world's tallest skyscraper. Image generated by AI.

    “Tallest Tower Surges Ahead”: Saudi Arabia’s Sky-Piercing Giant Breaks Records as Construction Accelerates Beyond Predictions

    June 7, 2025 at 9:46 AM
    Illustration of Merino sheep grazing among solar panels, enhancing wool quality and maintaining installations. Image generated by AI.

    “1,700 Sheep Through Solar Fields”: Scientists Reveal Stunning Results That Could Transform Farming and Renewable Energy

    June 1, 2025 at 4:57 PM
    Illustration of the Su Hai No 1, the world's first dedicated salmon farming vessel. Image generated by AI.

    “We’re Farming Fish in Open Seas Now”: China Unveils World’s First Salmon-Farming Ship to Revolutionize Global Seafood Supply

    May 29, 2025 at 8:08 AM
  • Tech
    Illustration of the competitive dynamics between OpenAI's ChatGPT and Google's search engine. Image generated by AI.

    “ChatGPT Won’t Kill Google”: Sam Altman Downplays the Hype While Quietly Reshaping the Future of Search With Every New Update

    June 16, 2025 at 12:12 PM
    Illustration of Meta's AI platform showcasing user interactions and privacy concerns. Image generated by AI.

    “Meta’s AI App Exposes Private Chats”: Shocking Feature Lets Users ‘Discover’ Strangers’ Intimate Conversations With No Warning

    June 16, 2025 at 8:04 AM
    Illustration of Disney and Universal's legal battle against AI company Midjourney over copyright infringement. Image generated by AI.

    “Disney and Universal Strike Back”: Entertainment Giants Sue Midjourney Over AI Copyright Breach in Landmark Legal Showdown

    June 16, 2025 at 6:58 AM
    Illustration of global leaders in research and development intensity, highlighting Israel's commitment to innovation. Image generated by AI.

    Not China, Not the U.S.: This Surprising Nation Now Tops the World in R&D Spending and Is Quietly Rewriting the Innovation Map

    June 15, 2025 at 3:58 PM
    Illustration of the dual nature of quantum computing, embodying both potential and challenges. Image generated by AI.

    “Quantum Computing Is Dead—Or Is It?”: This Shocking Revival Could Ignite a New Era of Unstoppable Tech Power and Scientific Breakthroughs

    June 15, 2025 at 9:48 AM
  • Transport
    Illustration of a Cybertruck on autopilot with its driver playing Grand Theft Auto V on a highway. Image generated by AI.

    Shocking Highway Scene as Man Lets His Cybertruck Drive Autonomously While He Plays Grand Theft Auto Behind the Wheel

    June 17, 2025 at 6:00 AM
    Illustration of the UK accelerating plans for autonomous vehicle deployment on public roads. Image generated by AI.

    “UK Hits the Gas on Self-Driving”: Bold National Push Could Make Britain the First to Fully Legalize Autonomous Cars Across All Roads

    June 16, 2025 at 5:51 AM
    Illustration of Canada's decision to freeze $32 million in public aid for Tesla. Image generated by AI.

    Canada Shocks Tesla by Freezing $43 Million in Funding—This Sudden Political Blow Could Reshape the Future of Green Tech Deals

    June 14, 2025 at 5:56 AM
    Illustration of SpaceX's Starship preparing for a mission to Mars. Image generated by AI.

    “Mars in 2026 is 50/50”: Elon Musk Unveils Plan for SpaceX’s Biggest Starship Yet Launching by Year’s End, Raising Global Curiosity

    June 13, 2025 at 4:56 PM
    Illustration of a revolutionary hydrogen-powered aircraft concept unveiled by Airbus. Image generated by AI.

    “Airbus Unveils Revolutionary Hydrogen-Powered Aircraft”: This Groundbreaking Concept Is Set to Transform the Future of Aviation

    June 11, 2025 at 10:12 AM
  • English
Rude Baguette

Europe’s position on data protection: The story of a huge gap between ideal and reality

Eirwen WilliamsEirwen WilliamsOctober 14, 2015 at 5:50 AM0
Share Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Telegram WhatsApp Email Copy Link
Follow Us
Google News
Share
Twitter Facebook LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Copy Link

cameras

It is not always easy to see a clear line in the difficult relationship Europe maintains with its core values and data protection policies. The current development aims to point out contradictions on the European fight for increased data protection and to give a sense of responsibility to our governments when it comes to protecting democracy and fundamental rights. But first, let’s start off with something positive. The EU Court of Justice rendered a remarkable decision on October 6th, invalidating the Safe Harbor principles. The Safe Harbor Privacy Principles allow US companies to register their certification if they meet the European Union requirements in order to transfer and process data collected from Europe to the United States. Facebook, Google and many more depend on this certification as under European law, companies are not allowed to send personal data to countries outside the European Economic Area unless they guarantee adequate levels of protection.

At the beginning of the litigation stands Mr. Schrems, an Austrian national, who lodged a complaint with the Irish data protection authority (the Data Protection Commissioner) against Facebook Ireland. He claims that, in the light of the PRISM revelations made in 2013, the Safe Harbor certification offers no real protection against mass surveillance of the data transferred to the United States and thus is contrary to the 1995 EU directive on data protection. The Irish authority rejected the complaint, on the ground, in particular, that in a 2002 decision the Commission considered that, under the Safe Harbour scheme, the United States ensures an adequate level of protection of the personal data transferred.

The European Court of Justice ruled on October 6th that the transatlantic Safe Harbour agreement is invalid as it does not guarantee sufficient data protection to EU citizens. Indeed, the 1978 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act as well as broad claims of national security, public interest and law enforcement requirements of the United States prevail over the Safe Harbour scheme and thus oblige US based companies to comply with their national law. The Court noted to this end that United States authorities were able to « access the personal data transferred from the Member States and to process it in a way incompatible, in particular, with the purposes for which it was transferred (…). »

The European Court of Justice reinforces with this judgement the European position on the necessary protection of private data. By doing so, the cancellation of the Safe Harbor agreement is the only possible consequence, mostly after the PRISM scandal revealed the inefficiency of this particular contract.

Is data transfer from Europe to the US endangered with this decision?

Absolutely not. EU law contains in itself significant exceptions that allow data transfer to third countries and thus derogate from the protective regime. For example, Article 26 of the 1995 EU data protection directive states that exceptions to data protection can be granted in different cases as for instance a public interest ground (a very broad term), defense of legal claims or simply by recovering the concerned person’s consent (the famous small boxes giving us the choice between « agree to terms or conditions » or don’t use my service).

Is the Court of Justice ruling going to have no effect at all considering data protection?

Not exactly. Even if this ruling has to be complimented per se, it is however very improbable that it is going to have a great positive impact on the protection of personal data. Besides the confusion it creates for multinational enterprises or even smaller start-ups operating both in Europe and in the United States, facing a significant legal vacuum, it is not very likely to have great effect in the US, whose officials already expressed their disappointment with this decision. The battle Europe is fighting against the United States on this particular point for many years, and probably for many more, is an ideological battle between two antagonistic positions. European authorities defend a very individualistic and intimate approach to personal data whereas overseas data are rather considered to be purely merchandisable information. If European authorities can impose their point of view on US companies operating within the EU, the possibility to have them complying fully with European law is, however, more than doubtful.

Sovereign data storage as a solution?

Lately, more and more recommendations arise proposing to have data of European citizens stored within the territory of the European Union to see European law applying to these data. However, Google’s data center in Finland or Microsoft’s data center in Ireland is not going to prevent these companies from transferring data to the United States in case their national law requires them to do so. The ongoing Microsoft case in the United States opposing the Department of Justice to the giant of the Internet has granted the DOJ in the first instance the right to demand emails of anyone in the world from any email provider headquartered within US borders. The case concerned an email account of Microsoft stored in Ireland which the DOJ claims to have a right to access to analyse suspicion of narcotics. The locality of the data centers is thus not as such a guarantee to have a unique law frame applying. Indeed, if the US Department of Justice requires private data to be analysed and is granted a legal right to do so, tech companies, even if their data centers are located outside US boundaries, will not be able to refuse and in these conditions it is going to be difficult for European law to be applied and to sanction companies for the violation of private data in case of a US legal obligation.

The Court of Justice ruling is, however, important for one main reason. If the data transfer is not going to be affected by the European Court of Justice ruling, US mass-surveillance of the data stored within Europe could be inhibited. Why? Simply because European authorities, aware of NSA spying practices, have power to control the flow of data transferred from Europe to America and thus to put pressure on the American government to stop mass surveillance of European citizens or of any data located within the European Union.

Europe is not credible when talking about the necessity to protect private data

However, Europe is losing credibility when it comes to giving lessons of morality to the United States for mass surveillance practices. If article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights claims the right to respect for private and family life, recent laws within the EU seem to derive significantly from this ideal. For instance, the recent French surveillance law (loi sur le renseignment) enables French intelligence agencies to spy on nearly everything without any serious legal challenges to overcome. Indeed, the bill sets up a special commission, (the CNCTR) supposed to arbitrate on surveillance of citizens. However, this independent instance is not granted sufficient powers to oppose itself to surveillance the government thinks is necessary as the latter can simply ignore the commission by invoking any broad argument of threat.

On top, the section on international surveillance, which has been invalidated by the French constitutional court earlier this year, is now envisaged again within a new law, under which almost all internet communications can be approved by the French authorities, without any form of meaningful checks and balance. “Allowing for such extensive, intrusive and indiscriminate mass surveillance is a flagrant violation of people’s right to privacy and freedom of speech,” states Sherif Elsayed-Ali, Deputy Director of Global Issues at Amnesty International.

While the « loi sur le renseignement » adopted in July already gives the government the authority to use mass surveillance techniques to combat terrorism, the new bill goes a step further and explicitly allows for mass surveillance techniques in the pursuit of a long and undefined list of objectives, including defending and promoting major foreign policy, economic and scientific interests and without any strict legislative control nor any other constraining control from another authority.

If Europe wants to have a credible voice in this ideological fight on data protection, it, first of all, has to protect its citizens from broad government surveillance. There is no trustworthiness in claiming the importance of the protection of personal data and at the same time allowing secret services to spy à la carte on whoever they desire. There is a difference between what is needed to monitor a few thousand dangerous individuals and allowing mass-surveillance of several millions of people. It is important to trace a line and to distinguish what needs to be distinguished not to authorise every justification on mass surveillance for vague reasons of threat. The desire of power to control everything is far more threatening than the individual danger we have to face.

In France, where the concept of the « Republic » is used over and over again in the public debate to revive controversies on French identity and immigration, it is rarely pointed out that these laws are everything but “Republican”. Article 16 of the Declaration of the Rights of Men and of the Citizen, the founder text of the values of the French Republic, states that: “Any society in which the guarantee of rights is not assured, nor the separation of powers determined, has no Constitution”.

Less verbal reassurances, more credible actions

It is time for European governments to take responsibilities and to stick to the values they claim, and are bound, to represent. We do not want the end of surveillance agencies, but we want them to stick to rules, determined and controlled by the legislator, and not the executive, and we don’t want mass surveillance of European citizens by their governments. And very incidentally, to come back to the beginning, only this can bring back legitimacy to the European fight  for private data protection.

To this end, we need public awareness and an appropriate debate on the extent of necessary surveillance. A debate involving every actor within our society, not only governments, and which comes back to the most basic democratic rule: the control of our institutions by the sovereign people and not the control of the sovereign people by the institutions.

Did you like it? 4.6/5 (20)

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

News, investigations, and analysis — our top stories every morning to start your day right.

Big Data data protection Facebook
Follow on Google News Follow on X (Twitter)
Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Telegram WhatsApp Email Copy Link
Previous ArticleZendesk acquires BIME Analytics to bring cloud BI to its enterprise clients
Next Article Uber takes aim at Deliveroo & Take Eat Easy, launches UberEATS in Paris
Related Posts
Illustration of James Howells searching for his lost Bitcoin hard drive in a landfill. Image generated by AI.

“He’s Still Digging”: Man Who Lost $700 Million in Bitcoin 12 Years Ago in a Dump Faces Stunning New Twist in His Hunt

Illustration of a lost hard drive containing 8,000 Bitcoins buried in a landfill. Image generated by AI.

He Just Gave Up €200 Million in Bitcoin: After 12 Years of Digging Through Trash, the Lost Hard Drive Is Gone for Good

Illustration of a man sleeping with black tape over his lips. Image generated by AI.

“Doctors Sound the Alarm”: Viral Mouth Taping Trend Called Dangerous and Completely Unproven by Leading Medical Experts

Add A Comment
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

News, investigations, and analysis — our top stories every morning to start your day right.

Trending
Illustration of a Cybertruck on autopilot with its driver playing Grand Theft Auto V on a highway. Image generated by AI.
Shocking Highway Scene as Man Lets His Cybertruck Drive Autonomously While He Plays Grand Theft Auto Behind the Wheel
Illustration of humanoid robots engaged in a kickboxing match in Hangzhou, China. Image generated by AI.
“Robots in the Ring”: These Two Humanoid Fighters Are Kickboxing With Shocking Agility in a Spectacle That Blurs Man and Machine
Illustration of artificial intelligence impacting gender equality in the workplace. Image generated by AI.
“AI Targets Women First”: Chilling Report Reveals How Automation Is Set to Erase Female-Dominated Jobs at Unprecedented Speed
News by category
  • English
  • Tech
  • Finance
  • Leisure
  • Transport
  • Science
  • Security
  • AI & Robotics
  • Energy
  • Sustainable Development
Information
  • Meet the Team
  • Legal notice
  • Privacy policy
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

News, investigations, and analysis — our top stories every morning to start your day right.

Facebook X (Twitter) RSS
© RudeBaguette.com. All rights reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.