Close Menu
  • English
  • Featured
    • AI & Robotics
    • Energy
    • Finance
    • Leisure
    • Science
    • Security
    • Sustainable Development
    • Tech
    • Transport
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us

Subscribe to News

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to receive the very best articles of the moment, handpicked and delivered straight to your inbox.

Illustration of tattooed tardigrades demonstrating living electronics (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.
“They Tattooed Tiny Creatures—and Unlocked Nature’s Cheat Code”: What Scientists Just Did Has the Whole World Freaking Out
Illustration of Mark Zuckerberg's luxury superyachts journey to Norway's fjords for a heliskiing adventure (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.
“Even the U.S. Is Shocked”: Zuckerberg’s 5,300-Mile Yacht Voyage and Helicopter Ski Drop Redefine Billionaire Excess
Illustration of humanoid robots competing in sports events in Beijing (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.
Beijing Launches World’s First Humanoid Robot Sports Games as Machines Compete for Glory in Jaw-Dropping Showdown
Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn RSS
Rude Baguette
Facebook X (Twitter) RSS
Newsletter
  • Featured
  • AI
    Illustration of humanoid robots competing in sports events in Beijing (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    Beijing Launches World’s First Humanoid Robot Sports Games as Machines Compete for Glory in Jaw-Dropping Showdown

    May 13, 2025 at 9:02 AM
    Illustration of the Amphibious Robotic Dog inspired by natural dog movements (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “This Robot Dog Swims and Sprints”: Nature-Inspired Machine Conquers Land and Water With Jaw-Dropping Agility

    May 13, 2025 at 8:05 AM
    Illustration of BabyBot mimicking infant feeding behaviors (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “This Robot Feeds Like a Baby”: Meet BabyBot, the Soft Marvel Revolutionizing Infant Feeding Research with Astonishing Precision and Unmatched Expertise

    May 11, 2025 at 3:51 PM
    Illustration of a tiny, shape-shifting microrobot navigating complex terrains (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “China’s Flying Lego Bot Is Real”: Miniature Microrobot Now Soars and Drives to Conquer Earth’s Harshest Terrain

    May 11, 2025 at 5:57 AM
    Illustration of artificial intelligence's learning process as a pattern recognizer and its challenges with bias and hallucinations (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “AI Doesn’t Think—It Mimics”: This Learning Method Reveals a Flawed Intelligence Model That Could Threaten Decision-Making Worldwide

    May 9, 2025 at 3:59 PM
  • Energy
    Illustration of Alpha Ring's Fusion AI Data Centre connecting global fusion research labs (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Fusion Labs Now Linked”: US Builds Super Device to Unite Global Reactor Tests and Accelerate Nuclear Breakthroughs

    May 11, 2025 at 7:08 AM
    Illustration of the breakthrough in fusion energy development, highlighting the resolution of magnetic containment flaws (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Scientists Finally Break the Fusion Barrier”: US Team Fixes 70-Year Energy Flaw in Stunning Scientific Breakthrough

    May 8, 2025 at 4:58 PM
    Illustration of researchers observing restricted heat flow in high-energy-density plasma using lasers (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    This Super-Hot Plasma Test Just Changed Everything: US Fires Up 180,000°F Fusion Blast in Monumental Scientific Milestone

    May 7, 2025 at 4:58 PM
    Illustration of bacteria generating electricity as a symbol of biobattery (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    “These Bacteria Spit Electricity”: A Groundbreaking Discovery Set to Ignite a Massive Green Energy Revolution across the United States

    May 5, 2025 at 4:03 PM
    Illustration of Divya Tyagi solving a century-old math problem to optimize wind turbine efficiency (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    Scientists Crack 100-Year-Old Math Mystery That Can Finally Unlock the Full Power Potential of Turbines Worldwide

    May 3, 2025 at 5:07 PM
  • Finance
    Illustration of Visa's integration of AI systems into digital payments (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    Visa’s AI Is Now Shopping for You: This Robot May Soon Swipe Your Card Automatically—and Mess With Your Mind

    May 4, 2025 at 8:07 AM
    Microsoft Strikes Unprecedented Deal: World's Largest CO2 Removal at 7.44 Million Tons, Setting New Environmental Milestone

    “Microsoft Strikes Historic Climate Deal”: World’s Largest CO2 Removal Pact Targets 6.75 Million Tons in Unmatched Green Push

    April 19, 2025 at 9:55 AM
    RLWRLD Stuns Tech World With $15.6 Million Fundraise to Revolutionize Robotics: Unleashing Unprecedented Innovations That Will Shock the Industry

    “Robots Just Got Smarter”: RLWRLD Raises $14.8 Million to Build Groundbreaking Foundational AI Model for the Future of Robotics

    April 17, 2025 at 6:47 AM
    Marshmallow's Meteoric Rise: British Migrant Insurance Startup Secures $90 Million, Surges Past $2 Billion Valuation in Unprecedented Move

    “Built for Outsiders, Backed by Billions”: UK’s Marshmallow Raises $90 Million as Migrant-Focused Insurtech Soars Past $2 Billion Valuation

    April 17, 2025 at 6:02 AM
    Why the tech industry needs a labor/union movement

    Why the tech industry needs a labor/union movement

    October 2, 2022 at 3:39 PM
  • Leisure
    Illustration of Mark Zuckerberg's luxury superyachts journey to Norway's fjords for a heliskiing adventure (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Even the U.S. Is Shocked”: Zuckerberg’s 5,300-Mile Yacht Voyage and Helicopter Ski Drop Redefine Billionaire Excess

    May 13, 2025 at 9:49 AM
    Illustration of the delayed release announcement for Grand Theft Auto VI by Rockstar Games (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    Total Shock for Gamers Worldwide: GTA VI Now Postponed to 2026 After Rockstar Vows to Redefine the Entire Franchise

    May 7, 2025 at 5:49 AM
    Illustration of the delayed release of GTA VI and its implications for the gaming industry (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Red Dead Proves the Wait Is Worth It”: Rockstar’s Masterpiece Shows Why GTA 6 Delay Could Deliver Gaming’s Next Big Legend

    May 6, 2025 at 4:47 PM
    Illustration of HBO's adaptation of The Last of Us exploring character depth and emotional storytelling (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    The Last of Us Reinvented: Season 2 Takes Bold Step Beyond the Game’s Limits in Stunning, Unforgettable Storytelling Move

    May 6, 2025 at 12:14 PM
    Illustration of the highly anticipated PlayStation 6 console with advanced features and technologies (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “PlayStation 6 Is Coming Fast”: Sony’s Next Console May Launch Much Sooner Than Anyone Predicted, Shocking the Gaming World

    May 6, 2025 at 10:03 AM
  • Science
    Illustration of tattooed tardigrades demonstrating living electronics (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “They Tattooed Tiny Creatures—and Unlocked Nature’s Cheat Code”: What Scientists Just Did Has the Whole World Freaking Out

    May 13, 2025 at 11:56 AM
    Illustration of the European Space Agency's ACES mission with the PHARAO atomic clock aboard the ISS (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “They’re Sending a Fridge-Sized Clock to Space”: This French Atomic Time Machine Could Change Everything About Navigation

    May 12, 2025 at 3:56 PM
    Illustration of the Black Beauty meteorite revealing evidence of ancient hot water on Mars (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Martian Hot Springs Found!”: Astounding 2011 Meteorite Purchase in Morocco Reveals Earth-Shattering Proof of Water on Mars, Valued at Over $10,000

    May 10, 2025 at 9:00 AM
    Illustration of Ray Kurzweil envisioning human immortality by 2030 through technological advancements (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Immortality Within Reach in Just 5 Years”: This Famed Futurologist Who Predicted the Internet and iPhone Reveals Astonishing Vision

    May 10, 2025 at 7:03 AM
    Illustration of a quantum communications network utilizing photons for secure data transfer between campuses (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    US Reveals Stunning Leap: This Groundbreaking Chip-Based Photon Network Set to Revolutionize Secure Quantum Data Transfers Across America

    May 10, 2025 at 5:46 AM
  • Security
    Illustration of the BlueWhale System, an advanced autonomous underwater vehicle designed for naval warfare, equipped with sophisticated sensors (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Unstoppable Sea Phantom”: This 40-Foot Drone Submarine Dominates Ocean Warfare, Packed with Massive Combat-Ready Payloads for Ultimate Naval Supremacy

    May 11, 2025 at 5:04 PM
    Illustration of the FP-1 long-range drone being unveiled during Ukraine's Infantry Day celebrations (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    Ukraine Unleashes Game-Changing 1,000-Mile Drone: This Aerial Beast Hauls 265-Pound Explosive Payload, Shattering Boundaries of Modern Warfare

    May 11, 2025 at 11:47 AM
    Illustration of Recce360 Deep Inspection Camera operating in a high-security, nuclear environment (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Indestructible Spy Bot Deployed”: US Unveils First-Ever Nuke-Proof Robot to Guard Missile Silos With Unstoppable Surveillance

    May 11, 2025 at 8:07 AM
    Illustration of the "White Emperor" fighter mockup showcased at the 2024 Zhuhai Airshow (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “China’s White Emperor Breaks the Rules”: Stunning New Fighter Jet Could Redefine Air Superiority and Shock Global Militaries

    May 10, 2025 at 3:56 PM
    Illustration of Latvia's autonomous kamikaze drone, BLAZE, engaging enemy UAVs (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    This Latvian Drone Has Russia Stunned: Under-60-Second Strikes Ignite Panic in Kremlin Defense Circles

    May 9, 2025 at 4:46 PM
  • Impact
    Illustration of Iceland's successful implementation of a four-day workweek and its impact on productivity and well-being (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Gen Z Was Right All Along”: Iceland’s 4-Day Workweek Proves a Massive Success Five Years After Bold National Shift

    May 12, 2025 at 7:54 AM
    Illustration of the majestic Jeddah Tower under construction, symbolizing architectural innovation and cultural preservation (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Saudi Arabia Unleashes Construction Fury”: This Mind-Blowing 3,280-Foot Jeddah Tower Set to Shatter Global Records and Redefine Skyscraper History

    May 6, 2025 at 3:59 PM
    Illustration of the ambitious Neom project and The Line skyscrapers amidst the Saudi Arabian desert (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Unprecedented Crisis Looms”: This Massive $500 Billion Construction Site Faces Catastrophic Delays as 10,000 Workers Sound the Alarm

    May 6, 2025 at 7:08 AM
    Illustration of revolutionary nickel extraction using hydrogen plasma to reduce emissions (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Green Battery Revolution Begins”: New Nickel Extraction Cuts Emissions by 84% and Could Transform the Entire EV Industry

    May 4, 2025 at 6:53 AM
    Illustration of global freshwater distribution and geopolitical challenges (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

    This Map of Earth’s Remaining Freshwater Reserves Exposes the Alarming Truth Behind the Coming Global Water Crisis

    April 29, 2025 at 4:53 PM
  • Tech
    Illustration of a person sporting a Continuous Glucose Monitor to detect early diabetes signs (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “This Wearable Sees Diabetes Coming”: New CGM Tech Detects Early Warning Signs With Unmatched Accuracy, Study Confirms

    May 13, 2025 at 7:07 AM
    Illustration of the Millennium M2000 Supercomputer revolutionizing AI-driven industries (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “This $2M Beast Obliterates Slow Science”: Millennium M2000 Supercomputer Is Smashing Research Speeds Worldwide

    May 13, 2025 at 6:13 AM
    Illustration of Jensen Huang, CEO of NVIDIA, leading the list of intellectually astute American CEOs based on linguistic analysis (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Elon Musk Made the List”: Linguistic Analysis Reveals the Smartest U.S. CEOs—and Some Names Will Truly Shock You

    May 12, 2025 at 12:13 PM
    Illustration of global leaders in research and development intensity with Israel at the forefront (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    Not China, Not the U.S.: This Unexpected Country Now Leads the World in Research and Development Spending

    May 12, 2025 at 10:02 AM
    Illustration of a programmer discovering fraudulent USB drives purchased from Amazon and developing a tool for data protection (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “All 12 Were Fakes”: After Buying Dozens of Fraudulent USB Drives on Amazon, This Man Released a Free Detection Tool

    May 12, 2025 at 9:10 AM
  • Transport
    Illustration of Airbus's innovative foldable wing technology for enhanced aviation efficiency (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    Airbus Shocks the Aviation World With a Jet Whose Folding Wings Dramatically Cut Fuel Burn and Boost Efficiency

    May 12, 2025 at 5:11 PM
    Illustration of a Tesla Cybertruck sitting idle in a parking lot (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    “Rotting on a Lot for Months”: This Shocking Tesla Discovery Left a U.S. Buyer Completely Stunned at Delivery

    May 12, 2025 at 6:58 AM
    Illustration of the Bugatti Bolide hypercar showcasing its extraordinary speed and performance on the Nürburgring track (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    Bugatti’s New Monster Hits 186 MPH and Leaves McLaren and Porsche in the Dust With Record-Shattering Acceleration

    May 11, 2025 at 10:14 AM
    Illustration of the Astute-class submarine showcasing its advanced stealth features and propulsion system (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    This Submarine Moves Like a Dolphin: Astute-Class Redefines Stealth Warfare With Silent Navigation and Lethal Efficiency

    May 10, 2025 at 5:14 PM
    Illustration of the Tu-160M supersonic bomber during a flight mission (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.

    This Russian Bomber Has U.S. Eyes Locked In: Pentagon Closely Tracks Tu-160M as Supersonic Show of Force Escalates

    May 10, 2025 at 12:08 PM
  • English
Rude Baguette

On Giving out Equity to Employees in French Startups

Eirwen WilliamsBy Eirwen WilliamsSeptember 9, 2014 at 8:45 AM06 Mins Read
Share Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Telegram WhatsApp Email Copy Link
Follow Us
Google News
Share
Twitter Facebook LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Copy Link

One major inconvenience in VC investing in French startups which consistently raises its ugly head is the complexity to incentivize key personnel with equity.

I’m not referring to the employees who eschew the upside potential afforded by equity in favor of fixed pay with high job security. While certainly understandable at certain positions in a startup, above a certain level of responsibility, this mentality does not usually endure (i.e. such individuals leave for more stable work environments, like large companies, or the startup never really achieves breakout growth, since scale is only as grand as the ambition of a startup’s people).

Rather, I’m referring to the startups that typically attract venture capital financing, in which the passion and enthusiasm for the endeavour extends well beyond the original founders to the entire management team and even rank-and-file employees. These people tend to value equity compensation as part of their overall remuneration packages.

VCs place a lot of value on equity compensation too, for two primary reasons: improved alignment between shareholders and personnel toward company success; and the affordability of employing strong, driven people without an unwieldy up-front cash outlay.

employee stock options

So already in France, where excitement over upside is not the human economic reflex that it is in the U.S. or Northern Europe, it’s a noteworthy accomplishment just to find a team clamoring for equity compensation.

Yet even with a collection of ambitious startup employees and enthusiastic investors eager to implement incentives that reward strong performance, the French tax code sure makes it tough.

For most of my tenure as a VC in France, my modus operandi on this topic was the following:

  • forget about stock options, as the penalizing fiscal cost practically wipes out the incentive
  • apply BSPCE wherever eligible, which had the most favorable tax treatment (BSPCE, or bons de souscription de part de créateur d’entreprise, are essentially ‘founder warrants’; however eligibility can be quite restrictive)
  • for those ineligible, grant BSA instead (‘general warrants’), which are available to anyone yet carry a fiscal cost (still better than options)
  • or as an alternative, consider granting free shares, which have straightforward fiscal treatment but other drawbacks

To broadly simplify, my choice of equity compensation instrument reflected four over-arching objectives:

  1. provide a genuine incentive to the employee, not a poisoned chalice. For example, requiring the employee to shell out money up front on an instrument that has an uncertain future gain is hare-brained (yet under French code this can actually occur)
  2. minimize the tax cost to the company (social and income)
  3. minimize the tax cost to the employee (idem)
  4. minimize any undesirable externalities (e.g. elements that could cause misalignments, extra administrative burdens, corporate governance issues, etc.)

From the investor perspective, I would generally favor ‘option-like’ instruments (i.e. like options or warrants) rather than free shares. While granting free shares to employees falls under a relatively straightforward fiscal framework, they can lead to misalignment. For example, let’s say I invest 6M€ in a company at a 15M€ post-money valuation and grant key employees free shares equivalent to 5% of the capital. If sometime later, an acquirer makes an offer to buy the entire company for 10M€, I would lose money on the deal, not even recouping my initial investment. On the other hand, the 5% holders of free shares would stand to gain 500k€, an infinitely positive return considering they received the shares for free, hence our interests are misaligned.

If on the other hand, I had granted the equivalent of 5% in options (or warrants) to the same key employees, the exercise price of these options would naturally be set at the same price of the investment transaction. Accordingly, the options would not be ‘in the money’ at any valuation below 15M€. So the option holders and investor would be more closely aligned.

Heads they win, tails we lose

In an ideal world, the fiscal code would acknowledge this uncertainty and allow me to grant options without an up-front cost to either the company or the employees. At time of redemption, if the options are worth something, the employees would pay some reasonable tax on their capital gain (i.e. proceeds minus exercise price).

The tricky part of all this has to do with social security tax. The administration’s fear is that a company might disproportionally weight an employee’s compensation with options, thus limiting the social tax intake. (I believe that in France this fear is unfounded for a variety of reasons, but that’s another debate). So to ensure that the company pays sufficient social taxes, the French government treats option grants essentially like salary, thus assessing social taxes on something whose ultimate value could be non-existent.

The BSPCE are exempt from this, providing a morass of eligibility criteria are met. The BSA are exempt if the beneficiary demonstrates a veritable risk, specifically by advancing money for them, otherwise the BSA could be construed as a gift, and thus treated like salary.

Hey, that Excel model looks familiar !

Now this is where I suspect the French government’s social tax department (called URSSAF) may have adopted my spreadsheet. During a tax audit of one of my portfolio companies a few years back, URSSAF carefully scrutinized a BSA grant that I had facilitated. They questioned whether the beneficiary paid enough for his BSA. If it was determined that he had not, his BSA grant would be re-qualified as a bonus, and thus merit substantial social and income taxes. I helped the employee demonstrate that he indeed had paid enough for the BSA. I did this by providing a Black-Scholes option valuation model to estimate the value of the BSA at the time of the grant and in turn proved that the employee’s investment exceeded the BSA value.

I could understand why URSSAF would want to penalize any unscrupulous practice of selling the BSA to the beneficiary for an almost negligeable sum. However, in this case, the up-front cost paid by the beneficiary for the BSA was significant, as demonstrated by my Black-Scholes model. URSSAF accepted our argument and the tax audit resulted in a clean bill of health. However, during the discussion, I had the impression that URSSAF was discovering a Black-Scholes option valuation model for the very first time.

Apparently for the past two years, URSSAF has been vigilantly applying a Black-Scholes methodology to every BSA grant they audit. Could my model have been a source of inspiration? (If so, I feel both honored and deeply apologetic!).

Regardless, the greater issue here is that granting equity incentives to stakeholders in a French startup requires navigating a labyrinth of mind-boggling complexity, and that is extremely unfortunate.

Did you like it? 4.6/5 (25)

Subscribe to News

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to receive the very best articles of the moment, handpicked and delivered straight to your inbox.

RudeVC tax
Follow on Google News Follow on X (Twitter)
Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Telegram WhatsApp Email Copy Link
Previous ArticleThe plot to box Netflix out of the French market
Next Article Here are New York City’s 10 Hottest French Startups – 2014 Edition
Related Posts
Illustration of Visa's integration of AI systems into digital payments (AI-generated, non-realistic illustration). Credit: Ideogram.

Visa’s AI Is Now Shopping for You: This Robot May Soon Swipe Your Card Automatically—and Mess With Your Mind

Microsoft Strikes Unprecedented Deal: World's Largest CO2 Removal at 7.44 Million Tons, Setting New Environmental Milestone

“Microsoft Strikes Historic Climate Deal”: World’s Largest CO2 Removal Pact Targets 6.75 Million Tons in Unmatched Green Push

RLWRLD Stuns Tech World With $15.6 Million Fundraise to Revolutionize Robotics: Unleashing Unprecedented Innovations That Will Shock the Industry

“Robots Just Got Smarter”: RLWRLD Raises $14.8 Million to Build Groundbreaking Foundational AI Model for the Future of Robotics

Add A Comment
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Subscribe to News

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to receive the very best articles of the moment, handpicked and delivered straight to your inbox.

Illustration of tattooed tardigrades demonstrating living electronics (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.
“They Tattooed Tiny Creatures—and Unlocked Nature’s Cheat Code”: What Scientists Just Did Has the Whole World Freaking Out
Illustration of Mark Zuckerberg's luxury superyachts journey to Norway's fjords for a heliskiing adventure (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.
“Even the U.S. Is Shocked”: Zuckerberg’s 5,300-Mile Yacht Voyage and Helicopter Ski Drop Redefine Billionaire Excess
Illustration of humanoid robots competing in sports events in Beijing (AI-generated, unrealistic). Credit: Ideogram.
Beijing Launches World’s First Humanoid Robot Sports Games as Machines Compete for Glory in Jaw-Dropping Showdown
News by category
  • English
  • Tech
  • Finance
  • Leisure
  • Transport
  • Science
  • Security
  • AI & Robotics
  • Energy
  • Sustainable Development
Information
  • Meet the Team
  • Legal notice
  • Privacy policy
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us

Subscribe to News

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to receive the very best articles of the moment, handpicked and delivered straight to your inbox.

Facebook X (Twitter) RSS
© RudeBaguette.com. All rights reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.