RudeVC: Know when to hold ’em, know when to fold ’em

RudeVC: Know when to hold ’em, know when to fold ’em

During a panel at a tech conference several years back, a seasoned and respected French early-stage VC that I will not name boasted about how he (of course it’s a ‘he’) had never had a portfolio company go bankrupt. Needless to say, this remark was an eyebrow-raiser for me about France’s venture capital sector.

My recollection of this incident was triggered the other day when I read Fred Wilson’s crisp explanation of what he defines as loss ratios. At the risk of summarizing far less eloquently than Fred does (and I encourage you to read his piece), loss ratios are defined as a percentage of VC investments that end up being worthless. They are measured either in: a) number of investments or b) value of investments, and divided by either a) the total number of investments, or b) the total value of investments, respectively. So for example, a VC fund that invests 100M€ in 20 companies, of which 8 companies go bankrupt, would have a Number Loss Ratio of 40%. If the VC invested exactly 5M€ in each company, the Value Loss Ratio would also be 40% (8 bankrupt companies * 5M€ / 100M€ = 40%).

Ideally, Fred argues, the Value Loss Ratio should be far inferior to the Number Loss Ratio. This makes perfect sense, because a good VC will take a “real options” approach to portfolio management. In other words, the art of being a good VC is to be smart enough to double-down on the winners and stop spending money and time on the losers. This simple theory is of course difficult to implement in practice, which is why it’s the primary notion that “separates the men from the boys” in venture capital as the adage goes (and hopefully one day the expression will be something more like “separates the women from the men”). Sticking with bad investments for too long is fraught with opportunity costs at many levels: it consumes funds which could generate a better return on another investment; it depletes time and mental bandwidth of the VC, it constrains talented employees of the startup in dead-end jobs, and it prevents ambitious entrepreneurs from moving on to the next venture.

Now back to the French VC’s boast (which, by the way, I ranted about four years ago here). “Never having a single portfolio company go bankrupt” would translate into a Number Loss Ratio of 0%. For a VC, this should not be something to brag about.

Don’t get me wrong. Bankruptcy represents an extremely unfortunate situation for the stakeholders of a company, even a startup. The entrepreneurs and employees who were dedicating most of their waking hours in relentless pursuit of a dream suddenly find themselves out of work. Particularly in France, whose job market is far less fluid than in most developed countries, bankruptcy is a painful event for the employees.

The silver lining of the cloud for these stakeholders, and admittedly it’s a not a cure-all, is that hopefully the bankruptcy liberates these people to migrate their talents into a more fulfilling career in a more promising business venture. And unless you’re in complete denial of free-market fundamentals, more capital allocated to the winners will translate into a larger pie and thus more opportunity for everyone.

Fred Wilson suggests a Number Loss Ratio around 40% for an early-stage VC fund and cites examples of some of the best-performing funds that hover around this level. This ratio should undoubtedly be lower for growth stage funds, but certainly not insignificant. Here in the French VC sector, to the extent that such talk characterized as ‘heresy’ five years ago is merely considered ‘shameful’ nowadays, I guess we’re making progress. But I’m not satisfied.

Sometimes you have to know when to walk away…



11 Responses

  1. 1and1 Login

    I’d like to find out more? I’d care to find out some additional information.

  2. plumbers

    After looking over a number of the blog articles on your web site,
    I really like your technique of writing a blog.
    I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back in the
    near future. Please check out my web site too and let me know your opinion.

  3. true penis growth

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on home remedies for penis growth.

  4. Max

    Hey there, You have done a fantastic job. I’ll definitely
    digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I’m confident they will be benefited from
    this web site.

  5. Hublot an

    This it not just amazing news for younger people, it’s wnderful for everybody who
    loves designer watches. There isn’t abstinent
    that watch has become one of many basal accessories for humans in avant-garde society.
    Super Copy The gold-tone blue choices are bold and delightful, plus the
    blue color is indeed vibrant.

    These feature alligator leather straps in the variety of colors
    and compelling inner dials, too as diamond-inlayed bezels
    on some models. Due the involvement with the SEALS from the
    popularity of Luminox watches, owners began to view a dramatic increase inside number of sales.

  6. dvr security recorder

    Analog CCTV recording systems happen to be the basis surveillance and monitoring for the
    past twenty years. Whether as part of your residential unit or set up in business, the newest
    CCTV surveillance system can often make difference between losing valuable property and keep it.
    Security cctv dvr Apartment CCTV Cameras are useful for highly Security rooms within a Building.

    If you wish to monitor your CCTV system via internet,
    you must get an IP address. No one paid any DVR negative here, but more channels
    with Direct TV and Dish Network at ATT, here are the details.

  7. the biggest nerf guns in the world general

    Among these noisy toys, the manned electric toy car gets the highest noise degree of 74~ 107 d – B.
    From a certain point of view, the Unholy Blight change looks as being a nerf, however for many situations it really is actually a buff.

    Nerf guns a The toys crafted by Bandai are one in the most well designed
    and stylish toys to try out with.

    Instead permit the child to experience with generic toys which might be not branded for
    any gender and let them have a free reign to pursue their imagination.
    Toys like a wordless book leave learners large
    self-construction and imaginary space, stimulate baby’s desire for expression and make a suitable language for baby free expression.

  8. garmin gps walmart

    Obviously smartphone applications are receiving better and better every day but, right now, this
    indicates the Garmin might be the best overall selection for even the modern triathletes.
    Of course, being the most recent model of Garmin GPS navigation, the display
    of the Garmin UNVI 1300 is no requirement to worry about.

    To top all this off, you merely enter in a very destination and also the garmin nuvi 205 portable gps navigator will take you there with turn by turn voice directions.
    The Garmin Forerunner 305 gps will be the best garmin needs to offer for runners.
    Garmin gps lifetime maps Once your Garmin is updated, head to the Garmin Garage and click on All Voices.

  9. eight

    Red clover blossoms: calcium (1310mg), magnesium (349mg), and potassium (2000mg); vitamins A,
    B, C, E, K; protein (20% of total). It is the lowest in fat of any candy I have reviewed thusfar.
    How many ounces in a cup of almond flour

  10. target hdmi to rca may

    They may have at least one USB port that supports playback of movies, music and photos files.
    In a globe where digital connections are king, VGA,
    or Video Graphics Array, delivers superior analog video transmission.
    Hdmi converter company Pricing is usually a very essential aspect to
    consider when searching for games.

    The G-Slate feels comfortable within our hands while typing, whether in landscape or portrait mode, and unlike the i
    – Pad 2 using its smooth-as-silk metal casing, the G-Slate isn.
    And that gives us to DVI, or Electronic Visual Interface, among
    the many finest alternatives.

  11. brightest off road led lights

    Most common emergency light we see on the roads would be the police lights which have these functions:
    . The displays on the two HTC Desire and
    also the Samsung Vibrant are AMOLED and both have
    480 x 800 pixel resolution. Best off road light
    bar Between the river interfering with his strength as well as the creature’s
    gold skin, the attack practically failed, but it did enrage the shark.

    If the quantity dialed is inside phone’s contacts, the name
    and number will pop up as you type. An emergency lightbar
    will also include several additional features which will help you in a massive amount scenarios.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.